The bilingual approach that I am experiencing right now is Mainstreaming with pull out classes. There are two students in the classroom that use Spanish as their native language. They are able to speak English fluently but are pretty behind when it comes to reading and writing. The teaching in the classroom only speaks English. I have observed that the teacher really sturuggles with figuring out ways to help these two students. These students get pulled out for ESL and the ESL teacher collaborates with the classroom teacher to share strategies and content that the class is working on. Chapter 11 of the textbook tells us this collaboration between teachers does not happen often, but in this classroom it does, so instead of missing classroom work, the bilingual students are doing the same work, just getting the extra help they need.
However, there are downsides to this approach. Sometimes, classroom teachers feel as if the bilingual students are completely the ESL teachers responsibility, which as we know should never be the case. Students also feel singled out when pulled out by the ESL teacher in front of all their monolingual peers. This can sometimes make them feel behind and frustrated. This mainstream pull out approach can actually be more expensive and harder for the school to do. They must hire more teachers, and find a classroom for ESL. Most of the time, ESL students are taught in a hallway, cafeteria or sometimes even a converted closet. This doesn't seem fair. So although this pull out approach is better than the regular mainstream approach, this still has its downsides and schools have to ensure the inclusivity and proper education for all.
No comments:
Post a Comment