EDBL Week 7 Case study
Meesuk Ahn
Introduction:
In this case
study, I will examine the process, and acknowledge the hardships of a bilingual
student. This particular person that I will present in this case study, native
language is Spanish however, we must consider every ELL has a different case.
Background:
The person that
I interviewed is my sisters’ friend who I am very comfortable with and have
known for many years. Her name is Valeria (we call her Val for short), she is 24
years old and moved to the United States with her family from Columbia when she
was 6 years old. Valeria grew up in a Spanish speaking only household and was
only introduced to English when she started school at the age of 6. Valeria
speaks Spanish at all times in her home with her family but will speak English
or codeswitch if they have guests over. Valeria’s parents have learned English
over time but still struggle with much of it, however her sister who is a year
older, and her brother who is two years younger, learned English with Valeria.
Valeria went on to get her bachelor’s degree and now works as a real estate salesperson.
Interview Questions:
1. What
were some of the troubles you faced going into a English only speaking
environment? What was the hardest thing for you?
2. Did
you find it helpful that your siblings were learning English the same time as
you were?
3. What
was the ESL program for you like in school? If you can remember, do you feel
like they honored your first language, or did they abandon it?
4. Was
it hard for you learning English in school but not being able to speak it at
home because your parents didn’t understand it?
5. Looking
back, do you feel like your struggles of learning two languages helped you
become a stronger individual?
Findings:
When talking one on one with Val, she told me a lot
about the internal struggles she went through at such a young age. “I actually
was really insecure about not being able to understand anything in school,
imagine you going to Columbia and sitting in a classroom with everyone speaking
only Spanish, it is terrifying as a child” she said. She explains how she felt
left out and lost for the first two years of being in the United States. She
told me that her parents would take English speaking classes at night to learn
themselves, but it was hard on her. However, she says she is now extremely
grateful for her upbringing and feels it only made her a better person. She’s
proud of her culture and is happy that she will one day be able to bring her
children up learning two languages.
Bilingual Assessment:
Val says her memories she has of her ESL class were
very positive. She actually still keeps in contact with her elementary ESL
teacher on Facebook. She said how accepting she was and how she always
acknowledged Spanish as her first language. As stated above, it took Val about
two years to start to get comfortable, but she says after her confidence was
up, so many doors opened up for her. English became second nature for her.
However, she did say that reading and writing was a slower process. She would
get frustrated that she was able to speak the language but not read or write.
Val says she was in ESL until 5th grade and even after that she
still struggled but was educated enough to work things out on her own by then.
Val said she felt as if she wasn’t completely biliterate until Highschool. She
said she had a high standard for herself that she couldn’t meet all the time
but looking back on it now, she knows that’s okay.
References:
Han, J., & Yao, J. (2013). A Case Study of Bilingual
Student-Teachers’ Classroom English: Applying the Education-Linguistic Model. Australian
Journal of Teacher Education, 38(2).
https://doi.org/10.14221/ajte.2013v38n2.3
Jiménez, R. T., García, G. E., & Pearson, P. D. (1995).
Three Children, Two Languages, and Strategic Reading: Case Studies in
Bilingual/Monolingual Reading.
American Educational Research Journal, 32(1), 67–97.
https://doi.org/10.3102/00028312032001067
No comments:
Post a Comment